雅思写作全真 Task 2 · Discuss Both Views（真实难度）
Discuss Both Views 是 Task 2 最高频题型，也是最容易写偏的题型——必须双方都讨论、自己立场清晰。本题为真实考试难度。
题目 Task
Some people believe that the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others, however, argue that education and rehabilitation are more effective.
Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
审题要点（为什么这题"真实难度"）
| 考点 | 说明 |
|---|---|
| 题型 | Discuss Both Views——必须讨论两方，不是二选一；漏写一方直接压到 6 分以下 |
| 陷阱词 | "the best way" / "more effective"——要回应比较，不能只夸一方 |
| 立场 | 双方都讨论后，自己的立场要贯穿全文，不能在结尾凭空冒出来 |
| 论证深度 | 真实考试高分作文不靠"讲道理"，靠机制分析：为什么长期监禁威慑有限？为什么教育针对根因？ |
范文（约 305 词）
It is often argued that longer prison sentences are the most effective means of reducing crime, while others maintain that education and rehabilitation programmes achieve better results. This essay discusses both approaches and argues that, while neither is sufficient on its own, investment in rehabilitation addresses the underlying causes of offending.
On the one hand, lengthy sentences can act as a powerful deterrent. The threat of spending years in prison persuades many individuals not to commit crimes they might otherwise have risked. There is also a practical argument: while offenders are incarcerated, they are physically prevented from reoffending. For serious violent crime, in particular, public protection is a legitimate priority, and no amount of education can substitute for the incapacitation that a prison term provides. This is why most voters instinctively support tougher sentencing.
On the other hand, evidence from countries such as Norway suggests that harsh punishment alone rarely produces lasting change. Prison systems focused almost exclusively on retribution tend to release offenders back into the same social conditions that drove them to crime in the first place: poverty, unemployment and limited education. The result is high rates of recidivism, often exceeding 60 per cent in jurisdictions that rely primarily on incarceration. By contrast, programmes that offer vocational training, psychological support and education have been shown to reduce reoffending by a substantial margin, because they equip offenders with the skills and self-belief to rebuild their lives.
In my view, the most effective strategy is a balanced one. Long sentences remain necessary for dangerous offenders, but for the majority of petty and repeat offenders, the resources spent on extending sentences would yield greater public benefit if redirected towards education and rehabilitation. Crime, after all, is rarely solved by treating only its symptoms.
逐段拆解（这篇为什么是 7.5+）
| 段落 | 功能 | 高分手法 |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | 改写题目 + 表明立场 | "while neither is sufficient on its own"——立场在开头就立住 |
| Body 1 | 讨论"长刑期"方 | 不只说"有威慑"，分析两个机制：deterrent（威慑）+ incapacitation（丧失犯罪能力）；承认"for serious violent crime" 的适用范围 |
| Body 2 | 讨论"教育改造"方 | 用 Norway 案例 + recidivism 数据（60%）做实证；对比机制：只惩罚会"release back into the same conditions" |
| Conclusion | 重申立场 | 明确 balanced，但资源向 rehabilitation 倾斜；最后一句点题 "symptoms vs causes" |
高分词汇与句式（可迁移）
学术词汇：
- deterrent / deterrence（威慑）
- incarcerated / incarceration（监禁）
- recidivism（再犯率——高分词）
- incapacitation（丧失能力）
- retribution（惩罚报复）
- vocational training（职业培训）
- underlying causes / symptoms（根因 vs 表象）
- yield greater benefit（产生更大收益）
句式：
- While neither is sufficient on its own, …（让步式立场句）
- While offenders are incarcerated, they are physically prevented from reoffending.（分词状语）
- By contrast, programmes that offer… have been shown to…（定语从句+被动）
- …would yield greater public benefit if redirected…（虚拟语气，高分）
自测清单
- 双方是否都讨论了？（漏一方 = 7 分以下）
- 自己的立场是否在开头就给出？
- 有没有具体机制/例证，而不是空喊？
- 有没有回应 "the best way / more effective" 这种比较词？
- 词数是否 ≥ 250（建议 280-310）？
常见失分点（真实考生典型错误）
- 只写一方：全文只夸教育，不提长刑期——任务回应（Task Response）直接 6 分以下
- 立场漂移：开头说同意长刑期，结尾突然说教育好
- 例证空泛：只写 "it is good for society" 而无具体机制
- 词汇重复：good / bad / people 循环使用，没有 deterrent / recidivism 这类学术词
No comments yet.